How to cut the cost of home insurance – without losing cover

Knowing how to cut the cost of home insurance (without compromising your cover) is crucial at a time when prices are rising all around us

With the cost of everything from putting food on your plate to fueling your car rising, the last thing you’ll want to do is spend a penny more than you need on your home insurance.

However, scrimp on your home insurance too much and there’s a risk it doesn’t do the job you need. You could find that you do not get the payouts you expect, or worse that claims are rejected altogether.

Getting a good deal on your home insurance isn’t about getting the cheapest price or shelling out for the most comprehensive plan; it’s about finding the best value and choosing a policy that suits you and your home.

GoCompare’s home insurance expert, Ceri McMillan, says: 'To get the right level of home insurance cover at the best price for you, it’s important to shop around. Policies can vary widely in price, and also in terms of the cover they provide.

'Ultimately, the most important thing is making sure your policy offers the right level of cover for you. So, read policy documents carefully before making your decision.'

From shopping around to advice calculating the value of your possessions, find out how to cut your home insurance bill without sacrificing the cover you need.

Blue living room storage with boxes

(Image credit: Future Plc/Dominic Blackmore)

1. Buy combined home insurance, but only if you own your home 

Home insurance is actually made up of two policies: buildings insurance to cover the structure of your home and contents insurance to protect everything in it.  It’s usually cheaper to buy both policies in a combined plan with the same insurer but always compare it against the cost of two policies to be sure. 

'If you own your own home you’ll need both, so consider buying a combined buildings and contents policy,' suggests Sarah Poulter, media relations manager at Aviva. 'But, if you rent, you would only need contents insurance.' This is because it is your landlord, as the owner of the property, that is responsible for the structure of the property and buying adequate buildings insurance. 

2. Shop around every time you renew 

It’s quick and easy to renew your home insurance with the same provider each year. However, even if it was the best deal a few years ago, it’s unlikely it still is.  So next time your policy comes up for renewal shop around on a comparison site, such as our sister brand, GoCompare, before you agree to another year with your current insurer. 

Once you’ve purchased your policy, make a note in your diary a month or so before it's due to renew to ensure you have plenty of time to shop around once again. Jessica Willcock, home insurance expert at says: “Historically, data has shown that shopping around about three weeks before your renewal date could save you the most money."

3. Choose the right level of cover for you 

Sarah Poulter says: 'It’s important to choose a product that best fits your needs. Many insurers offer tiers of cover and you may find that a lower tier is suitable.'

While a five star, bells and whistles policy might give you peace of mind, it won’t give you value for money if the additional benefits it offers aren’t relevant for you. There’s no point, for example, paying for extra cover in the garden, if your garden is basically the kids’ football pitch and there’s nothing more than old flower pots and junk in the shed.

Blue kitchen with island and pendant lighting

(Image credit: Future Plc)

4. Take care valuing your possessions 

Try and ensure you calculate the value of your possessions so you don’t end up buying cover you don’t need. Jessica Willcock says: 'Overestimating this by a significant amount could mean you're paying more, as insurers will see this as being a more expensive claim. But if you don't need £40,000 worth of cover, don't add it, and you might see your price reduced.'

5. Don’t confuse the rebuild cost of your home with its value 

If your home is damaged beyond repair, in a fire for example, your home insurance will cover the cost of rebuilding it. For this reason your insurer will request a rebuild cost figure for your house, however it’s important not to confuse this with its current market value, which will be higher. 

Willcock says: 'These are not the same thing, and matching the rebuild cost to the value of your home could see your price increase, as insurers will base the rebuild claim on this.' Few of us will know how to accurately estimate this figure, however there are online calculators that can help such as this one from the Association of British Insurers. 

6. Choose a higher excess level

The excess is the amount you need to pay towards any claim. Sarah Poulter says: 'Most home insurance policies have a standard excess if you make a claim, but you can choose to pay a higher excess to lower your premium. Just check you could afford to pay for it if you needed to make a claim.'

7. Check if your home is in a flood risk area 

If you live in a flood risk area ask potential insurers if they are signed up to the Flood Re scheme, suggests Sarah Poulter. This scheme makes home insurance more affordable for people who have homes with a higher risk of flooding. 'Some insurers are not part of the scheme and premiums may be higher for people living in high-risk areas, or they may exclude flood cover altogether, so it’s important to check.' 

8. Work on your no claims discount 

It seems counter-intuitive not to claim on your home insurance, it’s the reason you bought it after all. However, just like your car insurer, your home insurer will usually offer a no-claims discount. The more years you can go without claiming, the bigger the discount you’ll get and it shouldn’t usually matter if you switch insurers either. 

This means it’s worth thinking twice before putting in smaller claims, where you can easily afford the cost of repair, and keeping your insurance for bigger, more costly disasters.

9. Improve your home’s security 

Upgrading your home’s security will not only reduce the risk of a burglary, it may also lower your insurance bill.  Jessica Willcock says: 'Any burglary deterrents could ultimately mean you are less likely to have a break in and make a claim.'

Extension with bi fold doors into a living room

(Image credit: Future Plc/Chris Snook)

10. Stay on top of your property maintenance

Just as you want to minimise the risk of a break-in and losing possessions, if you want to reduce the risk of claiming it’s also important to take care of your property itself. This includes insulating your pipes (so they don’t burst in a cold winter), unblocking your gutters and removing tall trees.  In fact, insurers may not pay out for claims if they think the property hasn’t been properly maintained. 

11. Think carefully about add-ons 

When you take out your home insurance, think carefully about adding bolt-on cover to your policy such as accidental damage, for an extra fee. It could be worth its weight in gold if you like red wine and pale carpets but, if accidents are few and far between, or you’ve a slush fund that could cover any emergencies, it may be an unnecessary expense. Also think carefully about whether you need personal possessions to be covered away from – your phone, for example. 

12. Don’t double up 

If your possessions are covered by your home insurance, don’t fall into the trap of buying additional cover when you buy new items. Sarah Poulter says: 'You may be asked if you want to take out insurance when you’re buying a new sofa, carpet or mobile phone, so make sure you aren’t already covered by your home insurance, especially if you have cover for accidental damage.'

13. Look at multi-product discounts 

'Some insurers will offer you a discount, if you have more than one product with them, for example home, motor, travel and even health insurance,' says Sarah Poulter.  Buying all your insurance from one provider isn’t necessarily the cheapest option, nonetheless it’s worth taking advantage of these discounts if you’re happy with the insurance company in question and are the sort of person that likes to keep everything in one place. 

Blue home office with wooden desk

(Image credit: Future Plc/Simon Whitmore)

14. Pay for your insurance in one go 

Your home insurance can cost you several hundred pounds and so you may well be tempted to spread the cost of your insurance over the year by paying monthly. However, while some insurers will permit you to pay monthly, you are effectively borrowing from your insurer when you do this. As such interest will be charged so you will pay more overall as a result. 

15. Know the limits of your policy 

When you buy home insurance it’s vital to check your most valuable – and precious – possessions are covered.  Sarah Poulter says: 'Contents policies usually have a single-item limit, often between £1,000 and £2,000.' This is the maximum the insurance company will pay out for any one thing.

'Insurers will usually state that any items above this limit should be listed separately on the policy, to ensure that the items are covered.' You’ll usually have to pay more to ensure these items are properly insured, but this is one area where you don’t want to scrimp – especially if items have sentimental value too.