Why you shouldn't dig your garden this year, no matter what

The no-dig movement is trending, so here's why experts say you shouldn't dig your garden

Back view of garden furniture looking over a lawn
(Image credit: Alamy)

The no-dig movement – also known as (wait for it) lasagne gardening – has been steadily growing in popularity for a while now, and it's not hard to see why: it's one of the easiest ways to grow your own vegetables, fruit, herbs, flowers, and more at home.

'Gardeners have turned away from intensive cultivation, fertilisers and watering on a lavish scale,' says a spokesperson for the Royal Horticultural Society (RHS).

Instead, they are embracing planet-friendly gardening techniques and trying to become 'increasingly in tune with nature' – and the no-dig movement, which allows us to preserve the soil structure and the organisms that live within, such as beneficial insects, absolutely fits in with this garden trend.

The no-dig movement

While you'll likely still want to learn how to make compost for this one, there's no denying that the no-dig movement offers up a pleasingly lazy approach to our favourite pastime (albeit without the visual disarray of chaos gardening).

It's unsurprising, then, that more and more people are ditching their spades with glee – and public green spaces, including Roots Allotments in Croydon, are actively encouraging users to think 'no-dig' when planning their plots.

This year's RHS Chelsea Flower Show, too, will address the trend, as Japanese designer Tsuyako Asada explores no-dig (and no-waste) methods in her container garden, Tomie's Cuisine the Nobonsai.

A summer house sitting in a garden filled with flowers

(Image credit: Future PLC/SYM-ANTICS LTD t/a Brett Charles Photography)

'No-waste gardening and sustainability are central to our plastic-free garden at the RHS Chelsea Flower Show,' she says. 

'Our visitors will see how to retain water and reduce the need to add soil by reusing cardboard, newspapers, pruned twigs, stems and leaves.'

Of course, you'll likely still have some questions. Primarily, how on earth does a no-dig garden work? And is it really as good for our outdoor spaces as everyone claims? 

'For years we have been taught traditional methods of double digging to improve the structure of the soil and witnessed generations of gardeners before us doing just that,' says garden designer Matthew Childs.

Headshot of Matthew Childs
Matthew Childs

Matthew is an award-winning garden designer and has designed a diverse range of exciting landscapes both in the UK and internationally. His approach to garden design is to tailor gardens to each client and produce very human outdoor spaces which have a strong narrative, are a reflection of the people who use them and the surroundings in which they sit. 

'To now be told we have been doing it all wrong and should be doing the opposite might feel a little counterintuitive,' continues Matthew, 'but we should be open to new ideas.'

Beautiful vegetable plots at RHS Chelsea Flower Show

(Image credit: Future PLC/Heather Young)

'Talk to any gardener, and the topic of dig vs no-dig will inevitably come up,' agrees Joseph Clark (as in, yes, he of @JoesGarden fame!).

'It is the hot topic at the moment, and there is good reason for this.'

Joseph Clark, of Joe's Garden fame, poses in his backyard holding a glut of produce and wearing a straw hat
Joseph Clark

With some 25 years of gardening experience under his belt, Joseph Clark utilises his abundance of innovative ideas to create easy and fun recipes to help his audience lead more healthy and environmentally-friendly lives whilst also saving money. He recently launched a gardening subscription box service called ‘Garden with Joe’ which can be found here.

'Digging in compost and soil improvers into the soil has been a must-do for years in the eyes of gardeners,' continues Joseph. 

'Allotments up and down the country have traditionally been full of people digging away in the autumn. And, as a former member of Team Dig, I can tell you this is hard backbreaking work, and in all honestly a task I hated doing. 

'So, when a method which removed this came along, I was straight on board!'

A beautiful cottage garden, with furniture and a dog on the lawn

(Image credit: Future PLC/Penny Wincer)

As someone who has always hated digging in the garden, I know exactly what Joseph means: I was always going to support a gardening technique that means I can have an easier time with my garden border ideas (let alone my burgeoning crop of edimentals).

Still, plenty of you less lazy people will need more of a reason to sell your garden spade on Facebook Marketplace than 'a no-dig garden is easier on your back'.

With that in mind, then...

The pros of no-dig gardening

A no-dig garden doesn't just make life easier: it also encourages plants grow more healthily, and means fewer weeds, too – which is great news for anyone who spends their time googling 'how to kill weeds' on a regular basis.

Here are just a few of the benefits...

1. More time on your hands

Lavish lawn and garden of a country-style property

(Image credit: Polly Eltes Photography / Future PLC)

Once you cut digging out of the equation, you will find that garden maintenance is a doddle (and will take you much less time, too). Throw in the fact that you will have to spend less time weeding and watering as a result, and you will find yourself with plenty more time on your hands. 

Time to, say, grow a lemon tree from seed or something...

2. Far fewer weeds

View of nasturtiums, salvia in flower bed and no dig raised bed with well rotted manure in October garden in Carmarthenshire Wales

(Image credit: Alamy)

When you dig in your garden, you are 'also helping to bring weed seeds to the surface,' says Joseph. 

'Once they are on the surface, as anyone who has an allotment knows, they will soon germinate and become a real problem! You will then forever be on your hands and knees plucking out weeds all summer long.'

Matthew agrees, adding that he has 'certainly noticed in my my own veg garden that the less I disturb the soil the less weeds I get germinating competing with my crops.'

3. Better soil quality

Raised bed ready for planting in spring in a small back garden in rural Wales UK

(Image credit: Alamy)

There is a common belief plants grow better in loose, fluffy soil, but in fact they tend to fare much better when the soil structure is firm. 

'Out of sight, digging can break down the the natural structure of the soil, destroying networks of fungal growth, which can impact the ability of a plant's roots to access water and nutrients,' says Joseph. 

'When soil is dug, you can only get down so deep. What happens is you create a loose free draining layer of soil, usually around 10 inches deep, which is sat on top of a compacted layer of untouched soil. This can create poor drainage and can even lead to accidental overwatering and root rot.'

By choosing a no-dig garden, you are choosing to preserve the soil structure and the organisms that live within.

'This will improve the soil fertility as well as strengthen the nutrients it's able to offer growing plants,' says Nick Wood at GardeningExpress.co.uk.

4. A cheaper garden to run

Rock surrounded by flowers and poppies

(Image credit: Future PLC/Heather Young)

This one's a no-brainer: if you aren't spending money on weed killers, irrigation systems, fertilisers, and slow watering hacks, then of course  you will be saving money in the long run.

You are also likely to experience fewer failed crops – and plenty more healthy plants than usual, too. Which, let's face it, is excellent value for money.

5. Something that is better for the environment

A covered garden seating area surrounded by plants

(Image credit: Future PLC/Lizzie Orme)

That's right: much like rewilding and all of our favourite low-maintenance lawn alternatives, no-dig is one of those eco friendly garden movements that aims to make the world a better place.

'We have witnessed many examples of environmental damage and soil erosion in the world due to mankind’s activity, so it makes sense that less intervention with our garden soil is a better approach to ensuring more fertile soils,' explains Matthew.

'We have been digging crops for the last 100 years, and doing it successfully,' agrees Joseph. 'However, think about it as if you need to go to the shops and you have two routes to get there; one route is a straight 1 mile path, and the other is a 10 mile walk up hill, trampling a fragile ecosystem underfoot. 

'I know which one I would choose. Because, yes the outcome will be the same, but one is far harder and potentially more damaging than the other.'

How to embrace the no dig movement

If you've been persuaded to give the no-dig movement a try (and why wouldn't you? Imagine simply plucking potatoes easily from the soil as opposed to going after them with a shovel!), then you're in luck: it's incredibly easy.

What to do

Are you ready to get started on your no-dig garden? 

You need to:

  • Lay down a light-excluding mulch (eg cardboard) where you would like to plant 
  • Cover with your desired or available amount of compost (and layers of compostable materials, of course – hence the term lasagne gardening)
  • Plant straight into compost

That's it! Seriously, that's it. I promise there's nothing more to it than that (although if you don't believe me, you can check out this YouTube tutorial from no-dig pioneer Charles Dowding).

Hotbin Mini Composter | £249 at Amazon 

Hotbin Mini Composter | £249 at Amazon 

Easy to set up and use on any even surface, this hot composting bin enables users to recycle all food and garden waste and turn it into rich compost fast. Good for the planet, good for the garden, and good for us!

Of course, some maintenance will be required in your no-dig garden. 'You will need to add a layer of ‘mulch’ – normally compost – over the top of your beds each year,' explains Joseph.

'Once sprinkled on top you leave it, and as the name suggests, you don’t dig it in. From here the worms and other small creatures will work it into the soil for you, as well as eating the surface compost to break it down further, while also acting as a natural weed barrier.'

To be honest, it's a small price to pay for a dig-free gardening experience. If you need me, I'll be sourcing cardboard from my latest Prime Day purchases...


What is the no-dig method for gardening?

The clue is in the name with this one, as the no-dig method for gardening demands that we forget everything we've been taught about digging garden beds, and instead embrace an easier way forward. Essentially, your no-dig garden will see you mulch the ground, lay compost in beds on top of it, and plant accordingly. And, in a no-dig regime, garden spades are banished for all eternity, with weeds instead being controlled by shallow hoeing, hand weeding, and mulching

What time of year should I start no-dig gardening?

You can start your no-dig garden at any time of year, as there is usually always something to be sown. However, many suggest that the best time to begin is in the early spring, so that you can make the most of the growing season.

Is no-dig gardening any good?

Plenty of people swear by the no-dig gardening method, with the likes of gardeners and garden designers such as Joseph Clark and Matthew Childs piling praise upon it. Many claim that no-dig gardening makes for healthier plants, fewer weeds, better soil quality, and a more eco-friendly approach to planting, too.

What is a criticism of no-dig gardening?

'There is a misconception that no dig requires a lot of compost. Yes, in year one you will need a lot, but in the years that follow, you only need to add a couple of inches on top, which is arguably less that you would be digging in anyway,' says Joseph, dismissing one of the biggest no-dig cons out there.

He adds: 'Just a word of caution, though. While you can use any material that is compostable as a mulch, think about your climate. In the USA many no dig gardeners much with straw and hay.'

What is the best soil for no-dig gardening?

All soils work well with the no-dig method, even clay (in fact, clay soil is usually filled with helpful critters like earthworms, which should improve soil  quality further).

'I’ve got free draining sandy soil,' says Matthew, 'so I mulch annually and allow soil organisms to incorporate the mulch naturally. It really helps improve the soil structure and keeps it moist for longer.'

Will you be embracing the no-dig movement this year in your own garden? If you're anything like us, your shovel is probably already gathering dust in the shed, so you've nothing to lose at this point...

Kayleigh Dray
Acting Content Editor

Kayleigh Dray became Ideal Home’s Acting Content Editor in the spring of 2023, and is very excited to get to work. She joins the team after a decade-long career working as a journalist and editor across a number of leading lifestyle brands, both in-house and as a freelancer.