I wasted so much money on the wrong winter duvet – this is the one thing I wish I had known before buying one

How to avoid the same mistake I made

A bedroom with a bench at the bed of the bed
(Image credit: Dominic Blackmore)

As you've probably noticed, autumn is well underway. And it's beginning to affect nighttime temperatures.

If you've recently woken up feeling a little chilly under the covers, then your thoughts might have turned to sourcing the best duvet for the colder months. However, if you're considering investing in a dedicated winter duvet, hang fire.

There's one thing I wish I had known before buying my first winter duvet, and I'm here to share my duvet-buying mistakes so you don't make the same one.

I've been Ideal Home's Sleep Editor for the past four years, and during that time I've learnt a lot about sleep. Most importantly, I've learnt that the right bedding materials play a huge part in helping us to sleep better.

That's because a deep and restful sleep is more easily achieved if our body is the right temperature. If we get too hot or too cold during the night, we're more likely to slip out of deep sleep and into a lighter and less rejuvenating sleep.

A bedroom with a double bed and side table

(Image credit: Dominic Blackmore)

And that means we need a duvet that allows our body to regulate our temperature during the night. My big mistake when I bought my first winter duvet all those years ago was investing in one that didn't allow for this.

Like many of us, I invested in a winter duvet based on its tog rating. What is duvet tog? It's a measure of a duvet's warmth. Tog ratings start at 1 and go up to around 15.

A good summer duvet tog is around 4.5 tog. In the UK, a 10.5 tog duvet is usually a decent warmth level for spring and autumn and, in winter, most bedding experts will recommend using a 13.5 tog duvet.

However, what I didn't realise when I bought my first winter duvet is that staying warm and cosy throughout the colder months isn't all down to investing in a high tog duvet.

What I hadn't factored in was that although my priority was to stay warm, a good duvet should still offer breathability. This is what allows us to be insulated and cosy, but without overheating during the night.

A bedroom with a bed in front of a large sash window. The bed has white and orange pillows and a white duvet cover

(Image credit: Davide Lovatti)

Like many of us, the first winter duvet I bought was synthetic with a microfibre polyester filling. I don't remember consciously choosing to buy polyester. I think I was most likely swayed by its price, as polyester-filled duvets are usually the most affordable options.

What I now know is that polyester lacks breathability, and so although I was very warm under my 13.5 tog microfibre duvet, I would regularly find that some time around 3 am, I would become far *too* warm.

I'd wake up kicking off the covers because I was too hot and clammy, only to then start shivering and wrap myself back up in the duvet. This cycle would then continue throughout the night, and I often woke up not feeling very well rested as a result.

A few years later, I upgraded my duvet and invested in the luxury of a feather and down duvet fill. It was *very* warm and insulating and head and shoulders above my old synthetic duvet in terms of quality. But I found I'd still drift off super cosily, only to wake up too hot and spend the night with one leg sticking out from under the covers.

A navy bedroom with wooden details

(Image credit: Future PLC / Simon Whitmore)

That only changed when I put my first wool duvet through Ideal Home's duvet testing process. As it turns out, wool is a bit of a miracle fibre when it comes to sleep.

That's because wool fibres are naturally temperature-regulating and breathable. I soon discovered wool could keep me cosy and warm in bed, whilst still allowing my body to breathe and for excess body heat to dissipate through the duvet fibres. That meant no more overheating.

It was a game-changer for me. From my first night sleeping under a wool duvet, I slept far better. So much so that I've been known to take my wool duvet with me when I go stay at friends' houses, and I slightly dread a night in even the nicest five-star hotel because I know they're unlikely to have a wool duvet and I'll probably overheat.

I also soon discovered that wool is one of the best fillings for a duvet if you share a bed with someone who has a very different inner thermostat from you. This can make it difficult to find a duvet you both agree on.

There's the Scandinavian option of separate duvets, or even a sleep divorce with separate bedrooms, but wool solves both of those problems by creating an individual microclimate for both of you. So you could call it a relationship-saver, too.

A bed with a grey bedside table next to it

(Image credit: DOUGLAS GIBB PHOTOGRAPHY)

The downsides? A wool duvet is expensive compared to a polyester-filled duvet, and most are far harder to wash. In this regard, sunlight is your friend, as you can hang a wool duvet outside in the sun and the fresh air and UV rays will 'clean' it. Or you can invest in one of the few wool duvets that are machine-washable (more on that below).

However, for me, the improvement to my sleep quality is well worth overcoming those niggles. And the other benefit is that, unlike polyester, ethically-sourced wool is a sustainable and renewable material that also biodegrades safely at the end of the duvet's lifespan.

That means you can sleep more easily, not just because of wool's superior temperature regulation, but also because your duvet choice is far kinder to the environment.

Best wool duvets

If you want to take a leaf out of my book and make your new winter duvet a wool affair, these are the best wool duvets I've tested.

Amy Lockwood
Sleep Editor

Amy is Ideal Home’s Sleep Editor and the Ideal Home Certified Expert on Sleep. She's spent the last four years researching and writing about what makes for the best night’s sleep during the day and testing out sleep products to find the best-in-class by night. So far she’s clocked up over 10,000 hours of pillow, duvet, and mattress testing experience.

Our go-to for all things sleep-related, she’s slept on and under bestselling products from Simba, Emma, Hypnos, Tempur, Silentnight, Panda, and many many more.

As a hot sleeper, Amy is always on the lookout for the most breathable bedding, but she also leads a wider team of testers to ensure our product testing encompasses both hot sleepers, cold sleepers, front sleepers, back sleepers, side sleepers, and everything in-between.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.